Aston Villa has the better overall record in terms of head to head victories, at least up until now. Aston Villa and Everton have faced each other 62 times in top flight Premier League matches since their first head to head on the 25-Aug-1992. Aston Villa has won 27 times, with 17 of those victories coming at home. Everton has won 14 times, including 5 away victories. The teams have drawn 21 times. Across all their meetings, Aston Villa has scored 89 goals, while Everton has netted 70.